It’s a question… of balance
18th June, 2008“Teachers who have a vision of democratic education assume that learning is never solely confined to an institutionalized classroom… Embracing the concept of a democratic education we see teaching and learning taking place constantly… Democratic educators show by their habits of being that they do not engage in forms of socially acceptable psychological splitting wherein someone teaches only in the classroom and then acts as though knowledge is not meaningful in other settings. When students are taught this, they can experience learning as a whole process rather than as a restrictive practice that disconnects and alienates them from the world”. (Bell Hooks Teaching Community)
Why is it that practitioners of informal learning can align themselves so closely with the tenets of democratic educational philosophy?
I observe and pose such a question from the perspective of an informal educator and researcher, using media technologies to facilitate learning activities in out of school, informal, community settings.
There are a number of central characteristics evident in informal education practices which reveal a persuasion for socially just and holistic approaches:
- Relinquishing control of the learning process
- redefining the value of what constitutes learning
- encouraging self-awareness & reflection
- facilitating critical skills, freethinking & experimentation
- engaging though innovation and equal access & participation.
In raising the profile of informal learning and understanding its impact, all these elements require exploration. Adopting these in the context of formal education settings marks a distinct pedagogic sea change. I am engaged in projects which bridge the informal/formal educational divide. I recognize the enormous potential of such collaboration in terms of rebalancing the educational skew from a social space epitomised by didacticism, disjuncture and division to one fashioned by dialectic exchange, connection and equality.
To reiterate, balance, is key. Whilst formal education instruction is being increasingly eschewed, some critiques of informal learning approaches continue to murmur about abdication of responsibility by practitioners i.e. the hands-on/participatory yet hands-off paradox. However, working beyond institutional mindsets which stultify learner experiences require generative, flexible and non-hierarchical approaches to learning. These will take time to develop, appropriate and embed in order to be successful. Policy makers and educationalists must therefore be willing to support and develop effectual and truly democratic conditions which will allow these processes to be seeded, to grow and ultimately to the bear the rich fruits of learning they offer.

Futurelab is always looking for ideas. Find out how you can
Bob Harrison
Ben Williamson
Dan Sutch
Richard Sandford
Leon Cych
Martin Owen
Tim Reader
June 19th, 2008 at 5:36 am
Totally agree with the tone of this post. I have been saying similar for some time now … good to see that i am not on my own.
June 20th, 2008 at 7:09 pm
Speaking as a past-life professional democratic educator and also as a home-educator to two of my four children ( of whom Emma Agusita happens to be one! )….every generation since the advent of mass state education has had its advocates of democratic learning, the benefits of which Emma espouses. However, the most pertinent sentence in this article is the one which states that…’ policy makers and educationalists must therefore be willing to support and develop effectual and truly democratic conditions…..’Indeed so , but the history of state education has always been permeated by the dual nature of educational policy making and subsequent practice; on the one hand the overtly stated ideal of promoting the educational development of the individual to their full potential and on the other the covert practice of ensuring that, for the majority of pupils, this does not happen because if it did the social status quo would, effectively, end up being overturned. The thoughts of a cynical old educationalist ? No, just a warning to this generation of aspiring democratic educators not to underestimate the scale of what you are espousing ( revolution !) or the likely resistance you will encounter. Forewarned is forearmed…..GO FOR IT !!!!!!!